Paper woes and highs November 21, 2016Posted by mareserinitatis in career, education, engineering, papers, research, work.
Tags: citations, grading, homework, index, papers
I really, really hate grading papers. I’m not sure why I assign them, except that I hope there will be a decent amount of reflection and introspection on the part of the students as they’re writing them. However, I would rather grade problem sets or even lab reports than papers.
Part of the problem is that I’m looking for content and it’s not always in the same place as you go from paper to paper. In problems and lab reports there’s generally a set structure. For papers…it’s not entirely clear.
The other part of the problem is that they just aren’t engaging for me, so I end up falling asleep reading them. I’m one of those people who has a hard time sitting down to read a book, even for fun, unless it’s intensely compelling. I will, however, be fine listening to books on tape (or CD or iPhone or whatever they are now). I thank this means I need to hire a really good voice actor who can read them to me. At the very least, it would be slightly more engaging. But then I would still have to assign a grade. :p
On the up side of papers, some of mine are finally getting cited. The good ones, I mean. I have watched over the past three years as one of my least favorite papers on which I’m a co-author steadily gained and gained citations. I couldn’t figure out why except that it’s in a “hot” area. Now two of my papers are starting to pick up citations (and my h-index is starting to creep up). One of the papers is a good theory paper which was accepted to a rather selective conference while the other was more experimental in an area I’d like to keep doing research in (at least the theory aspect of it…don’t have the equipment to do experimental work now). I’m just going to keep my fingers crossed and hope that they pass up the crappy paper in a couple years. If either one does, it’ll be a reason to make something especially delicious and celebrate.